Trump’s Talked For A While About Extrajudicial Solution To Surge Of Migrants At Border
With firing of Homeland Security Secretary, he moves toward maybe making it happen
Update: How’s this for extrajudicial? Trump, at an informal media op in Texas says:
“But our military, don’t forget, can’t act like a military would act. ’Cause if they got a little rough, everybody would go crazy. So our military can’t act like they would normally act. Or, let’s say another military from another country would act.”
In other words, “too bad we can’t just shoot people”.
Here’s a clip from NBC News’ Twitter feed (click on it to play video):
Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen abruptly resigned Sunday evening following a meeting with the President, and while we don’t know for sure, we don’t think it’s too much of a stretch to suspect it’s a forced registration. That comes just a couple of days after Trump withdrew the nomination of Ronald Vitiello to be the new head of ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement), saying “we’re going in a tougher direction”.
Vitello spent most of his 30-year career with Border Patrol. Nielsen was former White House Chief of Staff John Kelly’s Chief of Staff when he was Homeland Security Secretary, and took over on Kelly’s recommendation after Trump moved him to the White House. Kelly left right after New Year’s Day, so Nielsen’s been without a “rabbi” for a while.
And while we don’t really know why Nielsen resigned (here’s a link to her resignation letter, which says next-to-nothing), it comes at exactly the same time as Trump’s attempts to stem the flow of asylum seekers to the Southern Border have started to become more intense and extraordinary in nature.
Over the weekend, Trump repeatedly ridiculed asylum seekers as fakes, and broadly characterized them as gang members. Here’s one clip illustrating that:
Nielsen will be remembered for separating migrant children from their families at the border as part of Trump and then Attorney General Jeff Sessions “zero tolerance” policy. What they were doing may have been inhumane, but it wasn’t clearly against the law.
In recent days, Trump’s talked about implementing his own rules that clearly would be. And thus might be an impossible order to follow based on current law. As we’ve mentioned, Trump wants to block migrants from ever setting foot in this country, “our country is full” has become his new mantra, and if they do, wants to turn them back without the courts getting involved.
Problem is, current law states:
“Any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States (whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including an alien who is brought to the United States after having been interdicted in international or United States waters), irrespective of such alien’s status, may apply for asylum….The applicant must establish that race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion was or will be at least one central reason for persecuting the applicant.”
But Trump seems like he’s on the verge of declaring he’s going to do it his way, possibly because it’s a national emergency, sort of like with his wall.
Thing is — and we’ve brought this up many times — there was a bipartisan immigration bill that flew through the Senate five years ago that would give Trump much of what he’s been demanding:
- End to “visa lottery”
- End to “chain migration”
- Establishment of “merit system”
- Expansion of entrepreneur visas, where immigrants bring large sums of money into the country with them
- Oh, and funding for a wall!
That bill was co-sponsored by Trump pal Lindsey Graham. While it didn’t directly alter asylum law, it did allow for decisions on asylum to be made by asylum officers, so those cases wouldn’t have to wait for a judge. Ultra Conservative members of the House blocked it because it also provides a 13-year path to citizenship for some undocumented immigrants already in the country. And that smacks to them of amnesty. Which also seems to be a no-go for Trump’s base. So that remains a problem now, because Trump and advisors like Stephen Miller, who has clearly gained influence since Kelly’s departure, don’t want a compromise, they only want the 1/2 of that bipartisan bill that keeps people out.
Trump seems to have plenty of support among his base for just going and doing it his way. Even we’ve gotten quite a few indications of that in the last few days. One response in particular suggesting if we’re not willing to personally take in a Central American migrant family, we should “get out of the way and let the President resolve the crisis…”
While Trump didn’t create illegal immigration and an increase in asylum claims, he bears at least some of the responsibility for the rush of people to the border. Trump’s telescoped every move he’s made on immigration. So people are figuring they better get in before they get locked out.
Nielsen will be replaced on an acting basis by Kevin McAleenan, the current head of Customs and Border Protection says Trump, but it’s unclear if that’s even legal. (And is the subject of much back-and-forth among lawyers on Twitter right now).